Where to start with Nationalism

The 5-book path

1. 1Start Here— the accessible entry point

   What Is a Nation?

   Ernest Renan · Nationalism

   The single most influential short answer to the question the whole subject turns on: what actually makes a nation? Renan rejects race, language, religion, and geography as the basis of nationhood and argues instead that a nation is a spiritual principle — a shared inheritance of memory and a present-day will to live together. It is the founding text of the civic, as opposed to ethnic, conception of the nation, and the obvious place to begin.

   To avoid a bubble: Pair with ethnic or romantic theorists of nationhood (Fichte, Herder) for the rival view that a nation is rooted in blood, language, and descent, and with Gellner or Anderson for the modern social-scientific account that treats nations as recent constructions.

2. 2Classic Foundation— the durable classic that anchors the debate

   Nationality

   Lord Acton · Liberal nationalism / classical liberalism

   A bracing classical-liberal counter-current within the nationalism canon. Writing in 1862, Acton argues — against the grain of his century's enthusiasm — that the multinational state, not the nation-state, is the true guardian of liberty, because a state that contains several nations cannot easily absorb the individual into a single collective will. It is essential for seeing that 'nationalism' was contested from within liberalism from the very start.

   To avoid a bubble: Pair with Mazzini or later nationalists who held that each nation deserves its own state, and with Renan for the civic-but-still-unitary conception of nationhood Acton is implicitly warning against.

3. 3Modern Bridge— connects the older argument to the present

   Imagined Communities

   Benedict Anderson · Nationalism studies

   A key text for understanding nationalism as a modern form of imagined political community.

   To avoid a bubble: Pair with conservative defenses of nation or liberal cosmopolitan critiques.

4. 4Opposing View— the serious counter-argument, to avoid a bubble

   Discourse on Colonialism

   Aimé Césaire · Anti-colonial theory / Négritude

   A concentrated anti-colonial manifesto that makes a claim no other text makes as starkly: that European colonialism and Nazism operate by the same logic, applied to different bodies. Essential for any serious route on empire, race, or anti-colonial liberation — and for understanding why the colonised rejected liberal humanitarian justifications for colonial rule.

   To avoid a bubble: Pair with Alexis de Tocqueville's writings on Algeria or John Stuart Mill's Considerations on Representative Government for liberal defences of colonial tutelage that Césaire targets directly, and with Hannah Arendt's The Origins of Totalitarianism for a different account of the Nazism-colonialism relationship.

5. 5Contemporary Lens— a current-day perspective

   The Virtue of Nationalism

   Yoram Hazony · National conservatism

   The most prominent contemporary defence of nationalism, and the book that gave the 'national conservative' movement its intellectual frame. Hazony reframes the central choice in international politics as one between empire and the nation-state, and argues that a world of independent national states is the best protector of collective freedom and diversity against universalist projects that would govern everyone by a single rule.

   To avoid a bubble: Pair with anti-colonial critics (Césaire, Fanon) and liberal cosmopolitans (Kant's Perpetual Peace) for the case that nationalism has at least as often been the engine of empire and exclusion as the guard against them.

Explore other traditions