ClassicIntermediatePrimary text

Utopia

Thomas More

Renaissance humanism

The book that gave us the word 'utopia' and founded a whole tradition of imagining the ideal society as a tool of political criticism. More describes an island commonwealth with no private property, communal living, religious toleration, and shared labour — and uses it to hold up a mirror to the cruelties and inequalities of his own England. Ambiguous, ironic, and endlessly debated, it stands at the head of utopian and socialist thought alike.

About the author

English humanist, lawyer, and statesman (1478–1535), Lord Chancellor under Henry VIII and a friend of Erasmus. A devout Catholic who was executed for refusing to accept the king's break with Rome and later canonized, More wrote Utopia in Latin as a work of humanist wit and social criticism that founded a literary and political genre.

Synopsis

In a framing dialogue, the traveller Raphael Hythloday describes the island of Utopia, where property is held in common, everyone works, gold is despised, war is shunned, and a wide religious toleration prevails — contrasting it sharply with the greed, enclosure, and harsh punishment of contemporary Europe. More leaves it artfully unclear how far he endorses Hythloday's radical vision, making the book both a proposal and a provocation.

Core passage idea

Paraphrase · Public domain

More's traveller argues that wherever there is private property, and money is the measure of all things, it is scarcely possible for a commonwealth to be justly governed or to flourish.

By tracing injustice to private property and money, More's Utopia opens the long tradition that links a just society to the sharing of goods — a root of later socialist thought. Its irony also founds the utopia as a device for criticizing the present rather than a literal plan.

To avoid a bubble

Pair with critics of utopianism (from Burke to Popper, who warned that blueprints for perfect societies invite tyranny) and with the question, which More himself leaves teasingly open, of whether Utopia is a genuine ideal or a satire of the very idea.

Reading note

Short and slyly ironic; read both the description of Utopia and the framing dialogue, where the real argument hides. It is the headwaters of utopian writing and an early challenge to private property.

Best paired with

Plato, Republic; Karl Marx, The Communist Manifesto.

Find this book