ContemporaryAdvancedBook

The Stillborn God: Religion, Politics, and the Modern West

Mark Lilla

Intellectual history / liberalism

A sweeping intellectual history of how the West learned to separate political life from divine revelation — and how fragile that achievement is. Lilla calls this separation 'the Great Separation,' begun by Hobbes, and traces both its development and the powerful nineteenth-century attempts to reunite God and politics. Arguing that political theology is humanity's default and liberal secularism the exception, he offers a sobering perspective on the persistence of religion in politics worldwide.

About the author

American historian of ideas (b. 1956), professor of humanities at Columbia University and a frequent essayist on political and religious thought. A self-described liberal, Lilla writes on the intellectual history of religion, reaction, and politics; The Stillborn God is his study of the West's uneasy separation of God from the state.

Synopsis

Lilla argues that for most of history political authority was justified by appeal to God ('political theology'), and that the modern West's 'Great Separation' — detaching political legitimacy from revelation, beginning with Hobbes — was a hard-won and unusual break. He traces liberal theology's attempt to reconcile faith and modern politics and its collapse, warning that the human impulse to ground politics in the divine never disappears and can return with force.

Core passage idea

Paraphrase · Modern copyrighted work

Lilla argues that the modern separation of politics from divine revelation — the 'Great Separation' — is a fragile and exceptional achievement, since for most of human history political authority has been grounded in God.

By treating secular politics as the exception rather than the rule, Lilla reframes the relationship of religion and the state: the question is not why some societies mix them but how the West ever managed to separate them — and whether that separation can last.

To avoid a bubble

Pair with thinkers who deny the separation is stable or desirable — from the political theology of Carl Schmitt to religious communitarians and post-liberals (Deneen) who want faith back at the center of public life.

Reading note

An elegant history of ideas; read it as the secular-liberal framing of religion and politics, against Schmitt's political theology and the post-liberal case for religion's public return.

Best paired with

Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan; Charles Taylor, A Secular Age.

Find this book

Search onlineSearch libraryBuy on Amazon