ContemporaryIntermediateBook

Nations and Nationalism

Ernest Gellner

Nationalism studies / modernism

The most influential modernist theory of nationalism: the claim that nations are not ancient and natural but a product of the modern, industrial age. Gellner argues that industrial society's need for a mobile, literate, interchangeable workforce educated in a single 'high' culture is what manufactures nations — reversing the common-sense view. Indispensable for understanding why nationalism appears exactly when and where it does.

About the author

Philosopher and social anthropologist (1925–1995), born in Paris to a Czech-Jewish family and a refugee from Nazism, who taught at the LSE and Cambridge. Gellner was a fierce critic of relativism and of what he saw as intellectual fashion, and his theory of nationalism — developed over decades and crystallised in this book — remains the benchmark that later scholars define themselves for or against.

Synopsis

Gellner argues that nationalism is the political principle holding that the cultural and the political unit should be congruent, and that this principle becomes irresistible only under industrialism. Agrarian societies, he shows, had no need to make culture and polity coincide; industrial society, requiring universal literacy and a standardised idiom for its constantly retraining workforce, does. Nations are therefore the effect, not the cause, of nationalism and the modern state's monopoly on education.

Core passage idea

Paraphrase · Modern copyrighted work

Nationalism is not the awakening of nations to self-consciousness: it invents nations where they do not exist — but it does need some pre-existing differentiating marks to work on.

Gellner's core move is to treat the nation as constructed rather than discovered. Nationalism does not express a nation that was always there; it builds one out of available cultural materials because industrial modernity requires it. This reframes every nationalist appeal to ancient roots as, at least partly, a back-projection.

To avoid a bubble

Pair with Anthony D. Smith, Gellner's own student, who argued that modern nations are built on pre-existing ethnic cores ('ethnies') that Gellner's pure modernism underrates.

Reading note

The argument is theoretical and can feel abstract; the pay-off is a powerful causal story you can test against cases. Read it alongside Anderson's Imagined Communities — both are modernists, but Anderson emphasises print and imagination where Gellner emphasises industry and education.

Best paired with

Benedict Anderson, Imagined Communities; Anthony D. Smith, National Identity.

Find this book