ModernIntermediateBook

Ideas Have Consequences

Richard M. Weaver

Traditionalist conservatism

A founding text of the post-war American conservative movement. Weaver traces the modern West's spiritual and moral decline all the way back to a fourteenth-century philosophical turn — the triumph of nominalism, which denied universal truths — and argues that abandoning transcendent standards led step by step to relativism, materialism, and cultural disintegration. The book that helped give traditionalist conservatism its intellectual self-understanding.

About the author

American scholar of rhetoric and English (1910–1963), longtime professor at the University of Chicago. A onetime socialist who turned to the right, Weaver became, with Russell Kirk, a founder of post-war American traditionalist conservatism; Ideas Have Consequences remains one of the movement's foundational books.

Synopsis

Weaver argues that the rejection of universals and transcendent truth — beginning with medieval nominalism — set Western civilization on a long descent into relativism, sentimentality, and the cult of material comfort. He diagnoses the symptoms in mass culture, the 'spoiled-child psychology' of modern democracy, and the debasement of language, and calls for a recovery of private property, piety, and a sense of objective, hierarchical order.

Core passage idea

Paraphrase · Modern copyrighted work

Weaver argues that the abandonment of belief in universal truths — the victory of nominalism — set in motion a long cultural decline, because ideas, once embraced, work out their consequences in a civilization whether we will them or not.

Weaver's title is his thesis: abstract philosophical choices, however remote, shape the moral life of whole civilizations over centuries. By locating modern disorder in a metaphysical error, he gave traditionalist conservatism a story about how the West went wrong — and what recovering transcendent standards would require.

To avoid a bubble

Pair with liberals and progressives who see modern individualism and material progress as gains rather than a fall, and with critics who find Weaver's narrative of decline-from-the-Middle-Ages nostalgic and his remedies vague.

Reading note

Compact and bracing, more cultural diagnosis than political program. Read it as a cornerstone of traditionalist (as opposed to libertarian) conservatism, alongside Kirk and Strauss.

Best paired with

Russell Kirk, The Conservative Mind; Leo Strauss, Natural Right and History.

Find this book

Search onlineSearch libraryBuy on Amazon