ContemporaryIntermediateBook

Black Rednecks and White Liberals

Thomas Sowell

Conservative cultural analysis

The most cited conservative challenge to the dominant account of race in America, and a useful opposing view on any race or justice route. Sowell argues that much of what is attributed to slavery or systemic racism is better explained by a transplanted cultural inheritance — that 'ghetto' culture derives from the 'redneck' culture of the antebellum white South — and that well-meaning liberal policies have entrenched the problems they meant to solve.

About the author

American economist and social theorist (b. 1930), senior fellow at the Hoover Institution and a prolific author across economics, race, education, and the history of ideas. A student of Milton Friedman who grew up in Harlem, Sowell became the most prominent Black conservative intellectual in the United States, known for marshalling history and data against prevailing progressive explanations of inequality.

Synopsis

A set of linked essays. The title essay advances the controversial thesis that the distinctive culture of the Southern 'cracker' and 'redneck,' itself imported from lawless regions of Britain, was absorbed by enslaved and then free Black Americans and persists in inner-city culture. Other essays attack the idea of a unique Black experience, compare 'middleman minorities' across history, and argue that liberal intellectuals have romanticised dysfunction.

Core passage idea

Paraphrase · Modern copyrighted work

Sowell argues that patterns often blamed on slavery or racism are better understood as a cultural inheritance — one that, in his telling, was shared with poor Southern whites and can change as cultures change.

Sowell's move is to shift the explanation of group outcomes from structure to culture, and to insist culture is not destiny. Whether one accepts it or not, the argument forces any structural account of racial inequality to specify exactly what work 'structure' versus 'culture' is doing — which is why it is valuable as a counterpoint.

To avoid a bubble

Pair with the structural and historical accounts it disputes — Du Bois, Mills's Racial Contract, Coates, and Collins — for the case that culture cannot be separated from the political and economic structures that shaped it.

Reading note

Read it as a deliberate provocation and the strongest popular statement of its position; then read its critics, because the cultural thesis is exactly what structural theorists most sharply dispute. Useful precisely because it makes the disagreement explicit.

Best paired with

W. E. B. Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk; Charles W. Mills, The Racial Contract.

Find this book

Search onlineSearch libraryBuy on Amazon